• Subscribe

Logo

Navigation
  • HOME
  • Leadership
  • Innovation
  • Finance
  • Marketing
  • Strategy
  • About
    • Upcoming themes
    • Advertise
    • Partnerships
    • The app
    • The journal
    • Contact Us
  • Subscribe

Purpose perishes with perfection

By Dialogue Review | on 22 January 2019 | 0 Comment
Blogs

Companies must avoid the authenticity trap, says Michael Chavez

READ THE FULL GRAPHIC VERSION

Sometimes Great Minds become distracted. The fast-food chain Chipotle, beloved of Mexican food fans, has a new chief executive after its visionary founder Steve Ells departed. Ex-Taco Bell chief Brian Niccol stepped in – with the unenviable task of restoring Chipotle’s reputation. Why? Chipotle incurred a 40% depletion in shareholder value in 2017 following a series of food safety scares and admissions by senior management that essential procedural standards had been neglected.

It was all going so well. The chain’s ad campaign ‘Cultivating a Better World’ was one of the most memorable in recent US history. Featuring folk music legend Willie Nelson singing the haunting chords of Coldplay’s ‘The Scientist’, it conveyed the dismal consequences – economic, environmental and social – of industrialized, processed food. The message was clear: Chipotle will buck the trend. Fast food need not be bad food. There is another way.

Yet the campaign and its messages buckled under the weight of their own contradictions when the food safety scandals hit. Chipotle’s stated purpose and its reality were at odds. Had Ells – a true innovator – allowed his Great Mind to wander? The disconnect was palpable. For all its attempts to command the moral high ground, Chipotle found itself picking itself up from the bottom. 

The advertising campaign represented an aspirational view of what Chipotle could become and how it could contribute to the world, not reality. The dream that Chipotle could change the fast-food industry itself was exactly that – an imaginative journey, not a realistic medium-term goal.

The Chipotle saga speaks to a core question: should your company’s stated purpose be aspirational? The answer is, only up to a point. Sure, your purpose should reach higher than your existing status, but it cannot be too lofty. It has to be realizable within a reasonable timeframe, practically observable, and within the bounds of your business framework. Traps lie ahead if it is stretched to the point of being disconnected from your fundamental business drivers. Defining purpose is as much about knowing your constraints as quantifying your aspirations.

Chipotle’s travails reminded me of the sage advice of another Great Mind, Deborah Wahl. Readers of this column will remember how Wahl, when head of US marketing for McDonald’s, reshaped its purpose. It was formerly ‘honest food’: an aspirational purpose similar to that of Chipotle, which attempted to channel public concerns about the provenance of its ingredients and healthy eating. “We pivoted away from it and readopted the corporate purpose which works much better: ‘making delicious, feel-good moments easy for everyone’,” Wahl said. “Purpose should help you get back to your core, not away from it.”

This sort of realism will help companies avoid what I term the ‘authenticity trap’ – having a purpose that is sufficiently removed from the day-to-day reality as to be counterproductive.

My colleague Dr Sudhanshu Palsule and I have been researching organizational purpose. Until recently, the research was revealing the moral and aspirational imperative behind purpose – something about ‘making the world a better place’ – without uncovering much in the way of warnings. This is concerning. The last thing business needs is for purpose to become another fad or entry into the dictionary of meaningless business jargon. Great Minds are, by their nature, also realists. They take care to avoid the perfect becoming the enemy of the good.

— Michael Chavez is chief executive of Duke Corporate Education

— A version of this article originally appeared on Forbes.com

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Print

Tags: authenticitycolumnperfection

Recent Posts

  • How to create the future

    20 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • The art of situational feedback

    18 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • Organizational excellence on the superhighway

    18 February 2019 - 0 Comment

Related Posts

  • Innovation in marketing is moving at a blistering pace

    15 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • Stop hiring for experience no one has

    15 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • Liz Mellon, on having the last word

    15 February 2019 - 0 Comment

Author Description

Dialogue Review

Dialogue Review

Comments are closed.

Browse the archive

Keep up to date with Dialogue

By entering your email address, you agree to receive emails from Dialogue

RSSSubscribe

Do you have a game changing team

Login

  • Register
  • Lost Password
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies.
To find out more, as well as how to remove or block these, see here: Our Cookie Policy
  • Most Read
  • Recent
  • Comments
  • Dialogue Classic: A softer hand for a hard-wired world

    18 August 2017 - 4 Comments
  • Dialogue Classic – The Gandhi principle: Five myths about soft leadership

    1 January 2016 - 3 Comments
  • Dialogue Classics: Four bad habits of super-smart leaders

    20 December 2017 - 2 Comments
  • Look into their eyes

    15 February 2018 - 2 Comments
  • The constant gardener

    26 March 2018 - 2 Comments
  • How to create the future

    20 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • The art of situational feedback

    18 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • Organizational excellence on the superhighway

    18 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • The five ambassadors of leadership

    18 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • The expectations management game

    18 February 2019 - 0 Comment
  • Effective leaders create a culture of service

    […] “Servant leadership is interpreted in different ways by...
    27 June 2018 - ILM Discussion: Trust and transparency -
  • The constant gardener

    Hi Bruce - thanks for your comment - I find that in collaboration,...
    14 March 2018 - richard watkins
  • Novartis: Culture is at the heart of performance

    Enjoyed reading through the article. I like the term OQ. I think it...
    8 March 2018 - Moitreyee Chatterjee- Kishore
  • Novartis: Culture is at the heart of performance

    OQ needs to be addressed a bit differently than IQ and EQ. The former...
    8 March 2018 - Rajiv Hazaray
  • The constant gardener

    "Leading collaboration is different from hierarchical leadership."...
    3 March 2018 - Bruce
February 2019
M T W T F S S
« Jan    
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728  

Who we are

Dialogue is an original, practical and world-class journal, which focuses on key issues and challenges encountered by business leaders and managers around the world.

The content of Dialogue will cover a wide range of topics relevant to leaders in different management functions and geographic locations, drawing on the opinions and research of some of the world’s most prolific business writers.

Top Posts & Pages

  • Download Dialogue App for free
    Download Dialogue App for free
  • HOME Dialogue Review
    HOME Dialogue Review
  • DIALOGUE JOURNAL: ARCHIVE
    DIALOGUE JOURNAL: ARCHIVE
  • The golden rules of luxury brands by James Ogilvy, Ogilvy & Co.
    The golden rules of luxury brands by James Ogilvy, Ogilvy & Co.
  • Agility, Chinese style
    Agility, Chinese style
© 2015 LID Publishing All Rights Reserved. | Privacy and Data Protection